Hamas: Wishful Thinking is No Basis for Policy Making (Huffington Post)
“‘If you look for truth, you may find comfort in the end; if you look for comfort you will not get either comfort or truth only soap and wishful thinking to begin, and in the end, despair.’ C.S. Lewis
Is the Palestinian Islamist organisation Hamas about to give up its strategy of armed resistance? Hopes were raised when Hamas leader Khaled Meshaal told Al Jazeera on 26 December 2011 that “all forms of resistance, especially armed resistance [i.e. the path of terrorism], are our right, but now, during the Arab Spring, we prefer the popular resistance and to focus instead on a unified strategy of popular resistance.”
I would be the first to dance a jig if there was a genuine rethink on the part of Hamas. A ‘new Hamas’ would indeed bring comfort. It would open the way to Palestinian unity and the extension of the West Bank nation-building strategy to Gaza. And it would boost the search for a two state solution, as well as encouraging other Islamist movements to give up violence. These are all glittering prizes, to be sure.
But it’s all ‘a bit previous’. And in the Middle East, as in life, it’s all about the timing. If European politicians get the timing wrong and drop the ‘no-contact’ policy too soon they could put back the clock on progress, inflict tremendous damage on the peace process and the undermine moderate politics throughout the region.
For four reasons, now is not to time bringing Hamas in from the cold.”
Read more…
QUOTE OF THE DAY
IAEA declares failure of Iran inspection mission
“Intensive efforts were made to reach agreement on a document facilitating the clarification of unresolved issues in connection with Iran’s nuclear programme… Unfortunately, agreement was…
Read moreCOMMENT & OPINION
26/01/2012
Hamas: Wishful Thinking is No Basis for Policy Making, by Lorna Fitzsimons
Hamas: Wishful Thinking is No Basis for Policy Making (Huffington Post)
“‘If you look for truth, you may find comfort in the end; if you look for comfort you will not get either comfort or truth only soap and wishful thinking to begin, and in the end, despair.’ C.S. Lewis
Is the Palestinian Islamist organisation Hamas about to give up its strategy of armed resistance? Hopes were raised when Hamas leader Khaled Meshaal told Al Jazeera on 26 December 2011 that “all forms of resistance, especially armed resistance [i.e. the path of terrorism], are our right, but now, during the Arab Spring, we prefer the popular resistance and to focus instead on a unified strategy of popular resistance.”
I would be the first to dance a jig if there was a genuine rethink on the part of Hamas. A ‘new Hamas’ would indeed bring comfort. It would open the way to Palestinian unity and the extension of the West Bank nation-building strategy to Gaza. And it would boost the search for a two state solution, as well as encouraging other Islamist movements to give up violence. These are all glittering prizes, to be sure.
But it’s all ‘a bit previous’. And in the Middle East, as in life, it’s all about the timing. If European politicians get the timing wrong and drop the ‘no-contact’ policy too soon they could put back the clock on progress, inflict tremendous damage on the peace process and the undermine moderate politics throughout the region.
For four reasons, now is not to time bringing Hamas in from the cold.”
Read more…
DAILY NEWS BRIEFING
Top Story: Court declares ultra-Orthodox military exemption law unconstitutional
Israel’s High Court of Justice ruled yesterday that a law exempting ultra-Orthodox seminary students from military…
LATEST ANALYSIS
Setting Standards: How the West should respond to political Islam, by Brig. Gen. (Ret.) Michael Herzog
In this new paper, BICOM Senior Visiting Fellow Brig. Gen. (Ret.) Michael Herzog argues that the West should use its economic leverage to apply criteria for dealing with Islamist parties, in order to influence their development.
SPOTLIGHT
Israel’s Democratic Futures
BICOM is pleased to present the perspectives of four experts - Alexander Yakobson, Amichai Magen, Nadav…
LATEST PODCAST
Crisis in Cairo: interview with veteran Israeli MK Binyamin Ben-Eliezer
The dramatic recent events in Cairo have profound implications for Egypt-Israel relations. To discuss these issues…
Analysis & Daily News Signup
Register to receive our free news summary and analysis emails.